A Bay Area business owner left a mountain of trash in a customer’s driveway after breaking a payment promise. Is he right?

Imagine renting a dumpster only to have the trash dumped right in your driveway. That’s what happened on San Pablo’s 19th Street after a rent dispute between a cleaning company and a customer turned messy (1).

According to Express Rental Dumpster — which bills itself as the top-rated trash removal company in the Bay Area — a moving out group set up a dumpster to dispose of the debris. Camera footage shows it was delivered and ordered, but owner Martin Perez said payment was never made.

“They kept saying, ‘Oh, I’ll pay later. I’ll pay later. I’ll pay later,’ and never did,” he told KTVU News. “Or say, ‘I’ll put money on the card so you can charge it.’”

After multiple collection attempts, Perez said the company returned to pick up the bin, which by then was full. Instead of taking it away, the contents were dumped back into the property.

A neighbor said the situation prompted the police to be called. Police then instructed the driver to move the debris off the sidewalk and back to the property.

“She said she paid $700 for it, and then suddenly, I saw him turn around and throw it all on the ground. I don’t really know what it was,” said a neighbor identified as Mary.

The situation worsened when scavengers began sorting through debris, further spreading the waste throughout the area.

According to San Pablo municipal code (2), property owners are required to keep adjacent sidewalks and surrounding areas clear, including removing any illegally dumped items. That means the responsibility for cleaning up could still fall on residents, even if they didn’t cause the mess.

Neighbors eventually stepped in to cover up and contain the debris, but the situation has since attracted the attention of local officials. San Pablo Code Enforcement has opened a case (3), which is likely against the tenant, who neighbors say still lives in the area.

While trash dumping may raise some eyebrows and even be seen as trivial, Perez said it comes at a cost in the end.

In the San Pablo area, renting a dumpster typically costs between about $600 and $770, depending on the size of the bin and the rental period (4). However, prices can vary widely when factors such as delivery fees, weight limits and handling costs are taken into account.

Perez told the station he shouldered the delivery and pickup costs. Transporting the debris to the landfill would cost hundreds more, increasing the cost of unpaid work.

Read more: How to apply Dave Ramsey’s 7 small steps to your own life

If you suddenly wake up and find a pile of trash outside your home, it’s important to document the situation (5). That includes taking photos, recording time and location, and recording details like license plate numbers or vehicle descriptions. People can also have access to local waste disposal programs to help dispose of their waste safely, especially if it’s not theirs to begin with.

But there’s one important thing to know: leaving trash on sidewalks or other public spaces is often considered illegal dumping and can result in fines. In California, this is considered a minor violation, but penalties can still range from about $250 to more than $3,000, depending on how many times it occurs (6). And in some cases, responsibility for cleanup may still fall on the property owner, even if someone else caused the mess.

For these San Pablo residents, who is ultimately at fault is still emerging as local law enforcement takes a closer look at the situation.

Join over 250,000 readers and get Moneywise’s best stories and exclusive interviews first — clear insights curated and delivered weekly. Sign up now.

We rely only on vetted sources and reliable third-party reports. For details, see our ethics and guidelines.

KTVU (1); San Pablo (2, 5) (3); Your House (4); Shouse Law (6)

This article originally appeared on Moneywise.com with the title: Bay Area business owner leaves mountain of trash in customer’s driveway after breaking promise to pay. Is he right?

This article is for information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.

Leave a Comment